Sunday, April 22, 2012

Husker Du - "Makes No Sense at All" (1985)

I always sensed that there was something rich in this song's harmonies and finally figured them out. Take a look at the extended chords implied by the melody in the first phrase here.

 photo f55730c6-0d2b-4397-a840-8c6aae38bf45.jpg

The G sung over the F chord in the second bar makes for an added ninth harmony, while the same note over A minor in bars three and four gives that chord a minor seventh quality. In both cases, it's the tonic pitch accounting for the harmonic extension, and this centering around G anchors the song in its key while the chords (which are really more native to C major) are stewing about. The second part of the phrase is sung in harmony and the last two notes are on D, which is also not a part of that A minor chord but is, of course, the fifth of the "home harmony."

It's impossible to say what the contrasting section of this song is; its different set of chords give the impression of a bridge, but the part is heard with different words after both of the verses. (There is no chorus.) The more functional G major chord vocabulary here provides a sense of relief from the strange harmonic goulash of the verse, but the melody remains insistent with its extensions, emphasizing D as a major ninth over the C chord in measure three and as a minor seventh over the E minor chord in measure four.

 photo ca06b12b-4bc1-44aa-9812-59c9482dcdf3.jpg


  1. So glad I discovered your blog! Seems like we have a pretty similar taste in music, but your analysis of the theory is really going to change the way I look at these songs (and songwriting in general). Keep up the good work man!

  2. Halo, i love husker du, do you have complete sheet for this song(better piano version)?Can you sand it to me?I play piano. Thanks James

  3. Ah, sorry, I don't. I made these little notation excerpts myself.